Why the scale goes up when you´re trying to loose weight – SHAF Coaching Newsletter

​

Hey friends,

There is a conversation I have with new clients almost every week. It goes like this: “I’ve been eating so little for so long, and I still haven’t lost weight. Now that we’ve started working together, my weight has gone UP. What am I doing wrong?”

The answer is almost always: nothing. Let me explain why.

YOUR BODY ADAPTS TO EATING LITTLE

When you eat very little for a long time, your body doesn’t just keep losing weight forever. It adapts. Your energy expenditure drops, you move less without noticing (fewer steps, more sitting, less fidgeting), your recovery gets worse, and your training suffers. Over time, the amount of food you think is a deficit may actually be close to what your body now needs to maintain.

So when you finally eat more, train harder and start a proper fat loss phase, you are not “overeating”. You are giving a body that has been in survival mode something to work with.

​

YOUR BODY ADAPTS TO EATING LITTLE

In the first weeks, the scale usually reflects things that have nothing to do with body fat:

→ Water and glycogen: More carbohydrates and more total food means your muscles store more glycogen, and every gram of glycogen holds water with it.

​
→ Food volume. More food simply weighs more while it moves through your system.

​
→ Stress and recovery: Chronic stress and poor sleep can make your body hold on to water. When you start eating more regularly, that can take a few weeks to settle.

​
→ New training: If you begin strength training, your muscles get inflamed and retain fluid while they repair. That is a normal sign of adaptation, not fat gain.

​
→ Your cycle: Water retention can swing by a few kilos across a month, and it is easy to mistake that for progress or failure.

None of these are fat. Real fat gain takes a sustained surplus over time, and it doesn’t happen in one week of eating more than you’re used to.

​

WHAT THAT LOOKS LIKE IN REAL LIFE

One of my clients came to me after years of eating as little as she could get away with. She was exhausted, training hard and getting nowhere, and she was convinced her metabolism was “broken” (or it was age related).

We started by raising her food intake and building her strength training up slowly. About three weeks in, she sent me a message that I see very often: the scale had gone up, and she was ready to go back to eating less. She told me it felt like proof that she couldn’t be trusted with food.

I asked her to hold off for two more weeks and to track a few other things alongside the scale: her lifts, her energy and her sleep. In that time, her squat went up, she stopped needing a nap after work, and for the first time in months she wasn’t thinking about food all day. Her weight settled and then started to trend down over the following weeks.

The scale was the last thing to catch up, while verything else had already been telling us it was working. She just didnt see it.

​

WHAT I WANT YOU TO LOOK AT INSTEAD

If the scale is your only measure of progress, a bad week can undo your motivation. So I ask my clients to collect evidence from more than one place:

→ Strength: are your lifts going up, or feeling easier?
→ Energy: are you getting through the day, and your workouts, without crashing?
→ Recovery and sleep
→ Hunger, cravings and mood around food
→ Measurements and photos over weeks, not days
→ Your weight trend over a few weeks, not a single morning

When these improve, your body is moving in the right direction, even if the scale hasn’t caught up yet.

​

THE BIGGER PICTURE

A fat loss phase after years of under-eating often starts with eating more and building strength first. It can feel scary and counterintuitive, especially if you have spent years being told that less is always better. But a body that is fed, strong and recovering is a body that can actually change.

​

YOUR VOICE MATTERS TO ME

Have you been stuck in the cycle of eating very little and not seeing results? Or has the scale ever scared you off something that was actually working? Reply to this email or send me a DM on Instagram @itsjanikame and I will give you some guidance if you need! 🙂

​

With strength & confidence,

Janika 🧡

Similar Posts